Are marketers making too much of generational differences?

A Gen Zer discovers a pair of running shoes on TikTok. A Gen Xer spots the same pair on Facebook. Different generations, different feeds, but perhaps the same reason for buying: They’re both training for a marathon.

Marketers have spent years dissecting the dissimilarities between generations, from the platforms they frequent to the creators they follow and the cultural references that catch their attention. But in trying to speak each generation’s language, are brands overlooking what brings their customers together?

Generational differences aren't imaginary, but marketers risk giving them more weight than they deserve. Media habits and advertising preferences vary by age, but they don't necessarily explain what motivates a purchase.

The challenge is knowing when age matters and when assumptions about it get in the way.

Different feeds, different expectations

Some 71.2% of Gen Z social media users discover new brands on TikTok, compared with 46.9% of older users, according to EMARKETER’s Consumer Path to Purchase survey.

Facebook flips the script. The platform drives brand discovery for 73.8% of social media users ages 30 to 80, compared with just 32.1% of Gen Z users, per the same survey.

These figures give marketers a useful map of where different audiences encounter brands. But a map won’t tell them what consumers are looking for when they arrive. “And it’s not enough to know where a cohort is online, you have to understand why they’re there,” said our demographics analyst Paola Flores-Marquez.

For younger consumers, TikTok is the place for entertainment as well as shopping, while Instagram helps them keep up with friends, and Reddit is where they go to research products, Flores-Marquez said.

Creative preferences also vary by age. Younger consumers tend to favor ads that feel native to their feeds, while older audiences may associate polished production with a higher-quality product.

Brands can’t simply transplant the same ad from one platform to another and expect identical results. But adapting an execution doesn’t necessarily require reinventing the entire campaign.

Shoppers don’t fit neatly into generational boxes

Consider two shoppers looking to furnish their living spaces. One is a Gen Zer moving into a first apartment. The other is a Gen Xer replacing furniture after a move.

Their budgets and tastes might differ, but both could be looking for durable, affordable pieces that fit their space. A campaign focused on those needs could speak to both without relying on a generational shorthand.

Conversely, two Gen Zers shopping for furniture might have little in common beyond their age. One might want the cheapest sofa available, while the other is happy to pay more for something that lasts.

Demographics help brands identify broad patterns, but individual circumstances often do more to explain what shoppers really want.

Knowing that a customer belongs to Gen Z might help determine where an ad should appear or how it should be presented. It doesn’t establish whether that customer cares most about price, quality, or convenience.

When brands build creative around assumptions about an entire generation, they risk overlooking the interests that connect consumers across age groups.

A good idea doesn’t need an age limit

Gap’s “Better in Denim” campaign featuring girl group Katseye shows how brands can draw on different generations’ cultural references without developing separate campaigns.

The advertisement paired the pop group with Kelis’ 2003 hit song “Milkshake,” giving younger audiences familiar performers and older viewers a recognizable soundtrack.

“Gap’s Katseye commercial to Kelis’ Milkshake was a great example of this: they combined two pop culture cornerstones for the individual generations and created something new and exciting for both,” Flores-Marquez said.

The campaign also delivered results. Gap reported that it helped drive traffic and double-digit denim growth, generating 8 billion media impressions and 500 million views.

Those figures don’t reveal how the campaign performed with each generation. But the creative gave audiences a reason to pay attention without requiring a separate idea for each.

Should brands abandon generational targeting? No. But it does raise a question about how much of their creative strategy should be dictated by age in the first place.

Before developing separate campaigns, marketers should consider whether the audiences they’re trying to reach actually want different things, or whether they simply encounter advertising in different places. Age can help brands determine where to reach shoppers and how to speak to them, but it shouldn’t be mistaken for an explanation of what they want.

The challenge isn’t making every campaign appeal to every age demographic. It’s knowing when the generational divide is worth crossing, and when it was never much of a divide to begin with.

This was originally featured in the EMARKETER Daily newsletter. For more marketing insights, statistics, and trends, subscribe here.

You've read 0 of 2 free articles this month.

Get more articles - create your free account today!