Influencer marketing has a new audience. Proving its influence is another matter

As consumers turn to AI assistants for shopping advice, creators’ reviews and recommendations can surface in chatbot responses long after the original posts stop circulating.

A shopper may never watch a creator’s video or recognize their name, yet still encounter information from that content when asking an AI assistant about which product to buy.

For marketers, that presents a measurement headache. If a creator helps inform a purchase without generating a view, click, or referral, how can the brand tell what that influence was worth?

US influencer marketing spending is forecast to reach $14.15 billion in 2027. With that much money riding on creator partnerships, marketers have good reason to question whether their existing metrics capture the full picture.

An influencer’s audience extends beyond their followers

Razorfish chief social and innovation officer Cristina Lawrence argues brands must consider how creator content contributes to AI-assisted product discovery.

“As consumers increasingly use generative AI to research products, categories and decisions, brands also need to think about which third-party voices help establish authority around the topics and questions for which the brand wants to be discoverable,” she said.

That could give detailed product reviews, demonstrations, and comparisons a longer shelf life than a typical sponsored post.

Consumers are receptive. Some 65% of recent AI-assisted shopping researchers said credible creator reviews increased their confidence in AI recommendations, according to IAB and Attest research covered by EMARKETER.

But wanting creator’s perspectives included in AI shopping advice doesn’t necessarily mean that the assistants are using them.

Our senior analyst Arielle Feger sees an opportunity for brands to make their product information easy to find and understand.

“Brands win an AI assistant’s recommendation by making themselves easy to understand and easy to cite,” she said.

That means clearly understanding who a product is for, what problem it solves, and what makes it worth considering.

Feger also recommends looking beyond brand-owned websites to reviews, expert commentary, and conversations in online communities.

For influencer marketers, the question is whether the creators they’re paying are contributing to those conversations in ways AI assistants can actually pick up.

A citation isn’t a sale

A creator’s review appearing in an AI response might look promising on a campaign report. But there’s a considerable gap between a citation and actually influencing a purchase.

An assistant might draw on a creator’s video alongside retailer listings, customer reviews, and product descriptions. Even when the creator gets the citation, it’s difficult to establish which source ultimately influenced the recommendation or whether the shopper acted on it.

Marketers already struggle with that uncertainty.

In an EMARKETER and Partnerize survey, 54% of US marketers said AI-driven discovery had undermined their confidence in existing attribution models. Only 8% could track its effect on revenue and conversions from beginning to end.

Those findings cover partner marketing broadly, but they expose a problem creator marketers also face.

Advertisers won’t spend more without evidence of a return either. Some 54.7% of US brand marketers and agencies cited proven higher ROI versus other channels as a leading reason to increase creator marketing budgets, according to EMARKETER and Spotter research.

If marketers can’t establish what a citation contributed to a purchase, counting those appearances adds another vanity metric to an already crowded dashboard.

Don’t pay for influence you can’t prove

The possibility of reaching AI-assisted shoppers may tempt brands to pay a premium for creators whose content appears in chatbot responses. But until marketers can establish the commercial value of those appearances, they’d be wise to keep their expectations in check.

That doesn’t mean abandoning creator content as a source of AI visibility. It means being more deliberate about what they’re commissioning.

A detailed product demonstration, for example, might answer questions about fit, functionality, or value that conventional sponsored post leaves unanswered. Brands could experiment with those formats while continuing to judge partnerships against established measures of performance.

Lawrence’s argument about looking beyond human reach and engagement gives marketers reason to reconsider what makes a creator valuable. It doesn’t necessarily give them a reason to spend more.

For now, brands gain more by learning which creator partnerships add useful, credible information to product discovery than by putting a dollar value on every AI citation.

The next influencer marketing opportunity may lie beyond the creator’s audience. The next expensive mistake would be paying for that opportunity before knowing what it’s worth.

This was originally featured in the EMARKETER Daily newsletter. For more marketing insights, statistics, and trends, subscribe here.

You've read 0 of 2 free articles this month.

Get more articles - create your free account today!