The data: Temperatures averaged 58.7°F across the contiguous US in October, 4.6°F above the 20th-century average and the fourth-warmest October in the 132-year record, per NOAA. That warmth is likely to carry through the holiday shopping season. Super El Niños typically peak in November and December, and this year’s is expected to last through early 2027, per NPR.
Why this matters: Warm weather is dragging down sales of cold-weather staples like sweaters, outerwear, and flannel sheets.
Gap said its assortment was overweighted toward cold-weather categories, and demand stayed weak from October into early November, prompting targeted price adjustments and additional promotions to clear inventory. The slower-than-expected start to Q4 also prompted Gap to lower its full-year outlook. It now expects net sales to be roughly flat, down from its previous forecast of 1% to 1.5% growth, and adjusted earnings per share of $2.29 to $2.34, down from $2.35 to $2.45.
Gap isn’t alone in citing a warmer fall as a sales headwind. TJX said unseasonably warm weather in the US and Canada was hurting demand in some categories, while Ross blamed higher-than-normal temperatures for “a really slow start” to its fall apparel sales. Boot Barn cited a weather-related drag as it lowered its annual comparable-sales outlook.
Warm weather has long been retailers’ go-to explanation for soft fall sales. Macy’s in 2015 attributed about 80% of its November–December comparable-sales decline to weak demand for cold-weather goods. And Burlington, which is heavily exposed to cold-weather items, has said elevated fall temperatures led shoppers to delay outerwear purchases in each of the past two years.
Implications for retailers: This year’s Super El Niño leaves retailers with little time for a cold-weather rebound, as elevated temperatures are likely to persist into the new year. That puts our forecast for 3.5% growth in winter accessories sales this year, including gloves, mittens, and earmuffs, at risk.
The window to sell cold-weather goods at full price is narrowing quickly, raising the stakes for inventory management. Gap shows the cost of reacting late: Targeted price adjustments and additional promotions weren’t enough to prevent the retailer from lowering its outlook. Retailers carrying heavy cold-weather inventory should consider targeted markdowns now rather than risk deeper discounts to clear out excess stock later.
You've read 0 of 2 free articles this month.
685 Third Avenue21st FloorNew York, NY 100171-800-405-0844
1-800-405-0844[email protected]