The situation: Taco Bell and Chipotle ended 2025 on two very different notes. While Taco Bell’s value positioning and menu innovation helped it gain fast-food share in Q4, Chipotle’s difficulties in attracting value-conscious customers led to its weakest year for comparable-sales growth since going public.

By the numbers: The two chains’ performances in Q4 reflect the considerable challenges in the QSR space, as well as the opportunities available to brands that can deliver compelling value.

Taco Bell pointed to “broad-based” growth across a number of cohorts, including higher-income consumers, families, and younger audiences.

• US comparable sales rose 7% YoY, which is all the more impressive considering the company was lapping 5% growth in Q4 2024.
• The chain credited innovation like its Baja Blast Pie, as well as its Luxe meal deals and limited-time offers like its Y2K-themed menu, for helping drive traffic.

Chipotle, on the other hand, struggled during what CEO Scott Boatwright told Bloomberg “was one of the hardest years to navigate from a consumer environment I’ve ever experienced.”

• On a FY basis, comparable sales declined 1.7%, the first contraction since the company went public 20 years ago.
• Chipotle expects similarly tough conditions this year, with comparable-sales growth forecast to be flat.

Implications for QSRs: Taco Bell’s ability to thrive while Chipotle struggles shows that food chains need more than value positioning alone to stay relevant in a challenged market. Customers—especially younger, Gen Z consumers—require constant innovation and menu refreshes to stay engaged, and are highly responsive to tactics like nostalgia-driven promotions or limited-edition tie-ins.

To succeed in this environment, QSRs need to deliver a constant stream of newness while ensuring that their menus are aligned with broader food trends—such as the mania for protein, growing demand for fiber, and interest in specialty beverages—to keep customers coming.

This content is part of EMARKETER’s subscription Briefings, where we pair daily updates with data and analysis from forecasts and research reports. Our Briefings prepare you to start your day informed, to provide critical insights in an important meeting, and to understand the context of what’s happening in your industry. Non-clients can click here to get a demo of our full platform and coverage.