The news: Kohl's reported a 1.1% comparable sales decline in fiscal Q1 2026, its best quarterly performance in more than four years, while exceeding Wall Street estimates on both revenues and loss per share.

New CEO Michael Bender said the company is "pleased" with the start to the year but is only "knocking on the door of growth."

Zooming out: While the improvement is real, Kohl’s still has a long climb to stable ground. The retailer’s net sales fell 1.7% to $3 billion, and it delivered a $14 million net loss. Management reaffirmed full-year guidance of comp sales down 2% to flat and adjusted EPS of $1.00 to $1.60.

The internal bright spots came from areas Bender has prioritized:

• Proprietary brands grew 6% on a comparable basis, led by SO in juniors.
• Digital sales rose 4%, and inventory was cut 8% YoY.
• Spring seasonal goods were up in the mid-teens following operational fixes.

Even so, the longer arc shows how far Kohl's has fallen: Q1 net sales of roughly $3 billion were nearly 25% below 2017. Bender told CNBC that higher gas prices, sustained inflation, and labor-market pressure are squeezing the retailer's lower- and middle-income customer base.

Implications for retailers: Even as Kohl’s cleans up its execution, its positioning remains the binding constraint. The retailer's middle-market stance leaves it without a clear value identity or a premium one, and that ambiguity has eroded its relevance over a decade. Shoppers have already picked sides: The off-price channel drew nearly twice the visits of department stores in Q1, per Placer.ai, with the treasure-hunt experience at Ross or TJ Maxx winning out over a trip to a Macy's or Kohl's. The leakage extends across the competitive set: TJX and Burlington capture value-seekers, Walmart and Target absorb essentials spend as consumers stretch their budgets, and category specialists like Ulta own beauty.

Kohl's strategic response—deeper private-label investment, fewer choice counts at higher depth, decluttered stores, and an AI-powered gift finder—addresses operational gaps rather than the underlying brand question. None of those moves complete the sentence “Kohl's is the place to go for ___.” Until the company makes that question easy to answer, the retailer’s existing customer wallet share will continue to migrate, and new customer acquisition will lean heavily on coupons.

The retailer’s challenges stem from its focus on stabilization rather than a strategy. Department stores that stabilize sales without rebuilding what they stand for will keep ceding share to retailers whose positioning is unambiguous. A more fundamental brand and assortment overhaul than the company has signaled will likely be required to convert this quarter's progress into durable growth.

This content is part of EMARKETER’s subscription Briefings, where we pair daily updates with data and analysis from forecasts and research reports. Our Briefings prepare you to start your day informed, to provide critical insights in an important meeting, and to understand the context of what’s happening in your industry. Non-clients can click here to get a demo of our full platform and coverage.