The news: JD Power’s newly released mobile and digital banking satisfaction studies issue a warning to banks: AI assistants are improving digital banking experiences in routine situations but failing at the moments that matter most.

Zoom in: Only 28% of bank and credit card app customers use virtual assistants, according to JD Power, but those who do generally report higher satisfaction with their digital experience overall. The biggest gains come when assistants help complete simple, routine tasks—particularly around navigation, account information, and basic servicing requests.

But customer satisfaction drops sharply as interactions become more complex. Users report frustration when trying to resolve fraud issues, dispute charges, or fix account problems through virtual assistants, especially when escalation to a human representative is limited. JD Power warns that many banks are creating “self-service loops” that deliver ineffective automated support during high-stakes moments.

Why this matters: Banks are pouring significant investments into AI-powered assistants and agents as they look to reduce servicing costs, improve digital experiences, and meet growing customer expectations for always-on support. But JD Power’s findings suggest many assistants are only effective for low-stakes tasks—not the moments where trust matters most.

That creates a risk for banks investing heavily in AI. While automation can streamline routine customer interactions, poor experiences when remedying fraud incidents, disputes, or account problems can damage customer trust and satisfaction. Seamless escalation to human support may become as important as the AI itself as banks compete to improve digital experiences and justify their growing AI spending.

Implications for banks: The bigger challenge is that digital banking adoption is nearing saturation. EMARKETER forecasts that almost 90% of the US population will use digital banking by 2029, leaving fewer opportunities to drive growth simply by bringing more customers online.

That raises the stakes for AI investments. As digital banking becomes nearly universal, competitive advantage will come less from offering digital access and more from delivering a better digital experience. Banks that use AI assistants to improve customer service, simplify routine tasks, and resolve problems effectively may be better positioned to win customers and deepen loyalty.

This content is part of EMARKETER’s subscription Briefings, where we pair daily updates with data and analysis from forecasts and research reports. Our Briefings prepare you to start your day informed, to provide critical insights in an important meeting, and to understand the context of what’s happening in your industry. Non-clients can click here to get a demo of our full platform and coverage.