I didn’t think much of this week’s “Amazon’s Black Friday deals aren’t real” headlines at first. They trace back to a Groundwork Collaborative report, which found 29.1% of 351 products featured on Amazon’s Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals pages in 2024 and 2025 cost the same or more during the events than in the month before.
If the headlines sounded familiar, that’s because they were. The Washington Post and The Guardian ran similar stories last year. And Amazon’s holiday shoppers didn’t flinch: Amazon captured 41.2% of US online sales last holiday season.
Shoppers like my wife are why those stories never stick. Like many Prime members, she starts and ends her search on Amazon. Bananas for breakfast, a bike light so our son can be seen riding home from wrestling practice, and the kids’ holiday gifts all go in the same cart without a second thought. Whether the Black Friday price is a true deal rarely enters the equation.
What got my attention was Amazon’s sharp pushback.
Amazon fired back, calling the analysis “deeply flawed” and Groundwork “a political advocacy group.” It argued that the report relied on a “cherry-picked, unrepresentative sample.” Amazon said Groundwork overlooked Early Event deals and included items that were never labeled as deals during the events. According to Amazon’s own review, 98% of the products Groundwork cited were priced at or below “the price over the past 30 days,” without specifying which price. Still, Amazon’s own rules let a sale price match an item’s 30-day low, which is the kind of “deal” Groundwork counted as no discount at all.
It’s easy to see why Amazon came out swinging. The report landed just days before the kickoff of Amazon’s 12-day Black Friday Week and Cyber Monday events, and Amazon has been shoring up its low-price reputation. In 2025, it began requiring that deals “typically” be priced at or below the item’s lowest price in the 30 days before an event, and it says it tightened that guideline this year. Its Alexa for Shopping AI assistant also lets price-conscious shoppers check how a day’s price compares with prices over the previous 365 days on Amazon. It’s a favorite of cheapskates like me who, unlike my wife, love to comparison shop and pore over data to make sure we’re getting a good deal.
Here’s the thing: Amazon doesn’t need the lowest prices. It needs attractive ones. If shoppers trust that Amazon’s prices are competitive, they won’t bother shopping around, especially Prime members who know their order will show up fast at no extra cost. That’s what keeps Amazon on top. We expect Amazon to capture 42.2% of US retail holiday ecommerce sales this year, about four times Walmart’s 10.4% and well ahead of everyone else. Shoppers like my wife are a big part of how it got there.
Their loyalty rests on an ecosystem that price comparisons can’t touch. Prime’s fast, free shipping removes the usual tradeoff between price and wait time. The Buy Now button lets shoppers purchase an item in a couple of clicks, which makes buying elsewhere feel like extra work. Amazon’s relentless push to speed up delivery widens that gap: Amazon delivered more than 1.5 billion items same-day or overnight in Q3 alone.
Amazon is also working its way deeper into shoppers’ daily routines. Adding perishables to same-day delivery gets more people shopping more often: Amazon says customers who buy perishables with same-day delivery buy nearly seven times more everyday essentials than those who don’t. On Tuesday, it went a step further, introducing ready-to-eat and heat-and-eat meals through Amazon Grocery same-day delivery and Amazon Now 30-minute delivery. Now, a shopper who orders a Caesar salad for lunch might notice a Lightning Deal and cross a gift off their holiday list without making a separate trip or visiting another retailer. That convenience is hard to beat, as long as Amazon’s prices stay just competitive enough.
That doesn’t mean Amazon can ignore price. Convenience buys it some slack, but if its prices drift too far from competitors’, shoppers who check, like me, will notice, and Amazon’s own price-history tool makes checking easy. Still, casting doubt on Amazon’s deals won’t pull shoppers away by itself. Retailers can cut prices or guarantee the lowest price, but those moves eat into margins and only work on shoppers who look beyond Amazon in the first place.
The fight over Black Friday pricing makes for good headlines, but it misses the bigger point: Holiday sales are won long before November. The retailer shoppers turn to for everyday needs becomes the default option when it’s time to buy gifts. Amazon is building that habit with same-day groceries and 30-minute meals.
Rivals don’t need to copy Amazon. But they do need to give shoppers a reason to regularly show up, not just in November. Amazon’s gaps show where to start: expert service, same-day store pickup, and curated assortments.
Programming note: I won’t have a column next weekend as we celebrate Thanksgiving (and Black Friday). I’ll be back in your inbox Dec. 5.
You've read 0 of 2 free articles this month.
685 Third Avenue21st FloorNew York, NY 100171-800-405-0844
1-800-405-0844[email protected]