The news: Nearly 3 in 10 products featured on Amazon’s Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals pages over the past two years, or 29.1%, were priced the same or higher during the sale event than in the month leading up to it, per an analysis of 351 products by Groundwork Collaborative.
About 9% of products were priced higher during the sales events than their lowest price in the preceding 30 days. That share rose to 27% when the comparison extended to 90 days, a period that includes Amazon’s Prime Big Deal Days sale. For example, an Apple Watch Series 10 was priced at $679.99 during Black Friday 2025, up from $602 roughly a month earlier.
Amazon has faced this kind of scrutiny before—The Washington Post and The Guardian have published similar findings over the past year—but this time Amazon aggressively pushed back on Groundwork Collaborative’s analysis, calling it “deeply flawed” in a post. Amazon said its own review of the deals Groundwork cited across 2024 and 2025 found that 98% of the products were priced the same or lower than their lowest price over the prior 30 days.
Why this matters: The report raises questions about Amazon’s discount claims just days before it kicks off its 12-day Black Friday Week and Cyber Monday deal events on November 19.
Although Amazon disputes Groundwork’s findings, it said it has strengthened its pricing safeguards this year to ensure that deals during shopping events almost always offer the lowest price in the preceding 30 days.
The retailer has also made it easier for shoppers to evaluate deals themselves. Its AI shopping assistant, Alexa for Shopping, displays up to 365 days of an item’s price history, giving customers greater visibility into pricing trends.
Those efforts are part of a broader push to reinforce Amazon’s value proposition. The retailer recently began integrating its Amazon Haul low-cost storefront more closely with its main marketplace, strengthening its appeal to price-conscious shoppers as household budgets remain stretched.
Implications for retailers: Amazon has good reason to defend its reputation for value. But its grip on shoppers extends well beyond price, which is why we expect Amazon to capture 42.2% of US retail ecommerce holiday season sales this year, more than four times Walmart’s 10.4% share.
Prime’s stickiness and Amazon’s relentless push to accelerate delivery give shoppers fewer reasons to look elsewhere: The retailer delivered more than 1.5 billion items same-day or overnight in Q3 alone.
Amazon is also finding new ways to make itself part of consumers’ daily routines. Its push to add perishables to same-day delivery creates more frequent shopping occasions—and more opportunities for impulse purchases. On Tuesday, it expanded that effort by introducing prepared foods through Amazon Grocery same-day delivery and Amazon Now 30-minute delivery, offering ready-to-eat and heat-and-eat meals for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. A shopper ordering a Caesar salad for lunch might also add a pair of AirPods to her cart, crossing an item off her holiday shopping list without making a separate trip or visiting another retailer. That convenience is hard to beat, provided Amazon’s prices remain competitive.
That means rival retailers can’t rely on skepticism about Amazon’s deals alone to win shoppers over. But Groundwork’s findings create an opening during the holidays, when consumers are especially focused on value. Lowest-price guarantees and price matching can give shoppers confidence they’re getting a good deal, while advantages Amazon can’t easily replicate—such as expert service, same-day store pickup, or curated assortments—give them a reason to shop elsewhere.
This content is part of EMARKETER’s subscription Briefings, where we pair daily updates with data and analysis from forecasts and research reports. Our Briefings prepare you to start your day informed, to provide critical insights in an important meeting, and to understand the context of what’s happening in your industry. Non-clients can click here to get a demo of our full platform and coverage.
You've read 0 of 2 free articles this month.
685 Third Avenue21st FloorNew York, NY 100171-800-405-0844
1-800-405-0844[email protected]