Product pages lack the reviews shoppers want most, potentially undermining confidence

The news: Online shoppers trust customer reviews and peer feedback more than indicators of item popularity or discount alerts.

  • 69% of online shoppers in the US and the UK say reviews and ratings matter more to them when building purchase confidence, compared with 7% for badges promoting deals and inventory alerts, per Syndigo.
  • Half are overwhelmed by the number of options available, leading 32% to lean on reviews to make their decisions. Only 7% immediately choose the most popular option.

Product detail pages (PDPs) are a crucial destination, with 39% calling them the most important location for customer feedback and social proof messaging. While badges promoting deals and inventory are on 99% of product listing pages, only 39% of PDPs contain social proof, and just 5% feature both social proof and clear product attributes.

Zooming out: Even as AI summaries and suggestions are starting to influence what consumers purchase and where they shop, human voices remain crucial. Customer reviews give shoppers a way to validate recommendations, fact-check brand claims, compare products, and decide if a given item meets their needs.

Retailers’ failure to place more emphasis on social proof may reflect immediate commercial needs and the relative ease of placing promotional badges compared with the work that’s required to collect and manage reviews.

  • Product badges and promotional placements add urgency, while social proof may be less predictable and not support the products a retailer most wants to sell.
  • Reviews don’t necessarily generate direct revenues and can be hard to manage because of fake feedback, outdated product information, or inconsistent volume across the product catalog.

Implications for retailers: Both promotional messaging and social proof are necessary. Badges can draw attention to sponsored items, while reviews can assuage shopper doubts and highlight use cases and attributes.

Treat social proof as a core part of the product page experience, but prioritize quality of feedback over quantity. Limiting review writing to verified customers, adding site tools that label any AI-generated content, and autopopulating reviews with product details like size and color purchased will help add depth to customer feedback without requiring more effort from them.

This content is part of EMARKETER’s subscription Briefings, where we pair daily updates with data and analysis from forecasts and research reports. Our Briefings prepare you to start your day informed, to provide critical insights in an important meeting, and to understand the context of what’s happening in your industry. Non-clients can click here to get a demo of our full platform and coverage.

You've read 0 of 2 free articles this month.

Get more articles - create your free account today!