The trend: 44% of Americans say US health policy should prioritize healthy foods, lifestyles, and disease prevention, compared with 32% who think it should favor medications and treatments, according to the latest Axios/Ipsos American Health Index. Another 22% are unsure which they prefer.

Why it matters: Despite momentum for healthy food policies from the Trump administration and HHS Secretary RFK Jr., disagreements within the medical community are causing skepticism among consumers.

Policy changes have reinforced the “food as medicine” narrative perpetuated by the Trump administration:

• A February 2025 executive order established the Make America Healthy Again (MAHA) initiative, which explicitly links diet and food systems with chronic disease prevention.
• In April 2025, the HHS announced its goal to phase out petroleum-based dyes in foods by the end of 2026; food manufacturers agreed under pressure from Kennedy.
• In January 2026, the HHS revamped dietary guidelines to prioritize meat and full-fat dairy, and launched an “Eat Real Food” ad campaign during the Super Bowl.

However, medical consensus and consumer sentiments reflect both alignment and skepticism with some tenets of MAHA:

• The American Medical Association agrees with federal policies to limit ultra-processed food and improve nutrition education in medical schools; meanwhile, the American Heart Association voiced concerns about the new food pyramid’s emphasis on red meat and full-fat dairy.
• 38% of US parents consider themselves supporters of the MAHA movement, although that support is highly polarized: 62% of Republican parents support the movement, compared with 17% of Democrat parents, according to an October KFF/Washington Post survey.
• Broader federal agency distrust compounds the issue: 69% of Americans believe foods with pesticides or artificial dyes are unsafe even if FDA-approved, and just 47% trust federal food safety standards, according to an October Ipsos survey.

Implications for healthcare providers and marketers: As diet and disease prevention move to the forefront of public policy, healthcare providers must act as frontline guides, reconciling the tension between nutrition and traditional medicine for patients who often view them as competing forces. Rather than allowing these pillars to clash, clinicians must integrate lifestyle changes and therapies into a single, cohesive treatment plan.

For healthcare marketers, the opportunity lies in equipping providers with nonjudgmental, evidence-based resources that validate patient interest in nutrition while firmly reinforcing the necessity of a balanced, integrated care.

This content is part of EMARKETER’s subscription Briefings, where we pair daily updates with data and analysis from forecasts and research reports. Our Briefings prepare you to start your day informed, to provide critical insights in an important meeting, and to understand the context of what’s happening in your industry. Not a subscriber? Click here to get a demo of our full platform and coverage.