Marcus Johnson: [00:00:00] Behind every bid is a supply decision most buyers never see. That's why they turn to Smart Supply, AI Digital's supply intelligence solution, scoring and gating every path before the DSP bids, so inventory arrives optimized for your KPI. You can learn more at aidigital.com
Hey, gang, it's Friday, November 20th. Tiffany, Grace, and listeners, welcome to Behind the Numbers, the market podcast made possible by AI Digital and Marcus. To join me for today's conversation we have, living in California, principal analyst and head of our financial services desk, Tiffany Montes.
Tiffani Montez: Hi there.
Marcus Johnson: Hello. Living in Austin now, Austin, Texas, senior analyst Grace Broadbent joins the show.
Grace Broadbent: Hi. Happy to be here.
Marcus Johnson: Thank you for being here. Today's fact
How long do you think the longest nonstop flight in the world is? In, I'll take miles or time.
Grace Broadbent: I know there's a new one, but I don't know where it goes to, but I think it's, like, [00:01:00] 16 hours?
Marcus Johnson: Okay. Tiffany, you want the over or the under?
Tiffani Montez: I say 20.
Marcus Johnson: Tiffany wins. New York to Singapore, 19 hours 15 minutes according to passrider.com.
New Jersey to Singapore as well is 10 minutes shorter. Five minutes shorter. It's basically the same thing, but New York to Singapore, 19 hours 15 minutes. Uh, and the route covers 9,532 miles, which is like if you're flying from New York to LA and back and back again and then back again without basically flying across the country four times, uh, without getting off the plane.
Tiffani Montez: What do you even do for that period- Oh ... like, that long of a time on a plane? Cry.
Grace Broadbent: Yeah.
Marcus Johnson: Sounds horrible.
Grace Broadbent: I feel like my feet would just go numb from sitting.
Marcus Johnson: Yeah. I did 12 hours. That was too much. Ooh. I was throwing things by the end. Uh, today's real topic, takeaways from the Binance hack.[00:02:00]
All right, remember that we have episode takeaways for everyone listening at the end of the episode, so make sure you check those out. But David Yaffe-Bellany of the New York Times explains that on October 29th, analyst firms Chainalysis, Elliptic, and TRM Labs, the FBI, and others say a North Korean hacking group, Trader Traitor, accessed Binance, the world's largest cryptocurrency exchange, and drained over $6 billion in the largest crypto heist of all time.
After Binance was founded in 2017, the exchange quickly became the largest and most important company in the crypto industry, processing as much as two-thirds of all digital currency transactions. New York Times article notes, "It provides a marketplace for people to buy popular coins like Bitcoin, Ether, uh, converting traditional currencies into crypto."
Shortly after the hack, it came to light that the criminal operation had started with an inadvertent download of malware in June, a recruitment scam in September, and then a raid of hot [00:03:00] wallets where billions of dollars worth of crypto assets were taken within a 20-minute window in October. Binance was forced to halt deposits and withdrawals, and posted on X they would cover any losses.
Um, Tiffany, I'll start with you. What was your main takeaway from the hack?
Tiffani Montez: I think the bigger takeaway for me is that there is no form of money that is inherently safe just because of the format that it takes. So we spent a long time talking about the security of cash, cards, bank accounts, and now digital assets, and this hack is reminder, a reminder that vulnerability often sits within the systems and the people that actually surround money.
So money moving from a different format, um, changes where security happens, but the need for trust still remains the same.
Marcus Johnson: Mm-hmm. Grace, the takeaway I had, um, which slightly relates to Tiffany's, is this nearly happens a lot Um, Sam Sabir of Axios was noting that [00:04:00] Binance said it detected and prevented 57 suspected North Korean-linked cyber incidents, in- including attempts involving fake job interviews and compromised software packages.
Data from PinDrop security shows that IT work- worker fraud is rampant, uh, this year. Last year, North Korean job applicants made up 1 in every 343 applications. This year, across PinDrop's customer base, those applicants now make up 1 in every 47. Um, so it nearly happens a lot. This also actually happens a lot.
Uh, and there's a bunch of cases, uh, from Mt. Gox, uh, 2014. Um, there was a bunch of hacks in the early 2010s, um, and that wreaked havoc. There was a Bitfinex, uh, hack in 2016, uh, of 72 million. That ballooned to 3.6 billion quite quickly. There's, uh, the FT- what happened to FTX. There's what happened to ByteBit.
There's what happened to Bitget. This does seem to happen a lot. Um, what was your takeaway, Grace?
Grace Broadbent: Yeah, [00:05:00] I mean, my main takeaway, obviously what makes this different is just the pure scale of it. Mm. At 6.3 billion roughly, it's... I mean, the biggest hack pr- prior to this was ByBit that you just mentioned.
Mm-hmm. And this is about roughly four times the size of last year, or of that hack last year. But I think actually a surprising takeaway for me was somewhat more positive, is that I think the biggest defense from this was actually the stablecoin issuers themselves. They actually, like, put up a pretty strong defensive against this hack.
They were helped freeze about 44% of the funds within pure minutes of it happening. Um, in comparison again to the ByBit hack, they could only recover 3% of the funds. So while it's happening, clearly all the time from the stats you're giving, the issuers are getting better at preventing this, um, and kind of showing a little bit [00:06:00] of the maturity of the system and how they're strengthening security.
Obviously you still don't wanna lose 60% of six billion, um, but they are getting better on the defensive. Um, so I think that's an interesting point to note.
Tiffani Montez: It is an interesting point because it, things are going to happen. But if you can actually shut things down quickly and provide confidence to your customers that you're able to do whatever it takes to stop it, and to, to even be able to say that you're gonna make sure that you pay back those funds, I think is really important in terms of any company's reaction to a cyber event
Marcus Johnson: Yeah, recovering a portion of the assets, um, has helped, um, a lot.
Spencer Halloran, head of markets at crypto trading firm GSR, saying Binance starting to recover affected assets had likely assuaged some of investors' concerns. Tether, Circle, and several other crypto firms had frozen about 3 billion in funds, uh, stolen, um, to help mitigate losses tied to the attack. And ByteDance has a [00:07:00] 1.2 billion secure asset fund for users to offset losses from security breaches and other events.
Grace Broadbent: I think this could have been not a bigger deal, but I think we could have seen an even larger market reaction had it come from a smaller crypto exchange. I think the pure size of Binance, like they somewhat have the money for this, like they are prepared for this. They are able to cover the losses. Where if it was a smaller exchange, you know, it would be a much- Interesting
different story, and I think it would have kind of larger implications.
Marcus Johnson: Yeah. Why was it just s- uh, just. Why was it 6.3 billion? 'Cause, um, Binance say they hold about 135 billion in total customer assets on the platform. Is it just... Like how does it work similar to a bank where you go in, you know, get the cash, you get as much cash as you can before the police show up?
Were they just trying to work as fast as possible in the 20 minutes it took them to steal this, and they were like, "We've been here too long, let's get out"?
Grace Broadbent: I believe it was the Binance itself and the [00:08:00] issuers that were able to block the funds. I think I-
Marcus Johnson: Oh, so they shut the water off.
Grace Broadbent: Yeah, I believe the blockchains put a halt on, um, halt on movement for the time being.
Marcus Johnson: Okay. Okay. Let's talk about the market reaction. 'Cause it does seem as though recovering some of the money has helped, but, um, in the week following the October 29th, uh, hack this year, Binance's native token, BNB, it was flat. Uh, initially it fell, then it rebounded. The next week after the midterms, the coin fell about 6%.
Bitcoin followed a similar trends. Uh, Tiffany, what should we make of the market's reaction to crypto following the hack?
Tiffani Montez: I think we should look at the market's reaction as a measure of confidence. So, you know, any major security incident creates questions about an institution and the infrastructure supporting it.
So crypto as an example. And those questions also affect the broader market. So the bigger point for me is trust and how financial [00:09:00] institutions depend on consumer trust in whatever financial instrument it is, um, that they're providing or protecting or storing.
Marcus Johnson: Mm-hmm Yeah, Kelly Yee, head of research at the trading firm Talos, said the market treated this as an operational shock, not a systemic one
Grace Broadbent: I agree with that in terms of the way this ha- hack happened was through people.
It was not, you know, because of an inherent risk or an inherent, like, way the blockchain is formed and, like, code broke within it. Mm-hmm. It was hackers that are really good at using AI and doing deep fakes. And f- I mean, I think they had one of the, their targets who worked at Binance, I think they had him go through, like, five different job interviews before the actual hacking took place.
Like, they are getting very advanced, and so I see it more as almost like an AI risk, a deep fake risk, than a inherently [00:10:00] a cryptocurrency industry risk. I think that same thing- Yeah ... could happen essentially at any large company, and they might not be, you know, taking out the funds, but they could be, you know, exposing other secrets or money at traditional banks and things like that.
Mm-hmm. So I think it's almost more of an AI story than really a cryptocurrency story.
Marcus Johnson: So speaking about that, um, Tiffany, referring to the use of AI in cybersec- uh, cyber attacks this year, Sean McNulty, derivatives trader at market maker AQC Tech, said, "People see this as the tip of the iceberg and expect more hacks to happen given the AI capabilities.
If Binance, the world's largest exchange, can be hacked, then no one is safe." To what extent do AI-powered systems introduce emerging cybersecurity risks for financial institutions?
Tiffani Montez: I think this is where the attack gets really interesting. So once the attackers actually had access to the employee's computer, Binance says that it did use an internal AI tool to move [00:11:00] deeper into the organization and to reach employees involved in its wallet infrastructure.
But I don't know that the company has actually said how the AI tool was used, so I don't know that we can call it- Mm-hmm ... an AI hack. As Grace said earlier, I think really the, the vulnerability, I said earlier that you've got money, and then you have the people that surround the money, and in this case, what the, the issue was is the people surrounding the money.
That is actually how they were able to get into the, into Binance and actually infiltrate the system. So when you start thinking about it from that perspective, it shows why AI security is actually gonna matter more to companies in any institution. And if, and if an attacker gets access to an AI system within a- another system, it can help them actually understand the organization, connect them to other systems, and then make that, that breach much more powerful than it would've done if you just had access to one single system.
Marcus Johnson: Mm-hmm. [00:12:00] It basically felt that it's a phishing scam, right? They, they were able to get information or access to things through people as opposed to using code or AI to just, um, take over a machine, um, without, um, at least as it was part of it, uh, without anyone knowing about it. Uh, can the hackers realistically convert these billions of dollars in stolen crypto into usable money?
How difficult would that be for them?
Grace Broadbent: Quite difficult. I mean, it can happen, but it will have to happen slowly. Um, like with previous hacks, it has to happen over months, um, and over, you know, some shady networks and often at a steep discount. Um, so you know, but I think it's the same as, you know, any hack.
If you compare it to, I feel like there's been really big art heists recently. It's not really easy to offload expensive art because on the black market, y- they can trace it. Right. Um, so it's kind of the same risk there. It's, you know, [00:13:00] stealing it is one thing, profiting off of it is a whole other.
Tiffani Montez: Unless you buy, take black market money and buy black market items.
Grace Broadbent: Yeah.
Marcus Johnson: Um, analyst firm TRM said the hackers have already moved $2.4 billion in crypto beyond any issuer's reach, there's a quote there. Um, what happens if a significant portion of the stolen f- stolen, uh, funds are never recovered?
Tiffani Montez: I think recovery isn't actually guaranteed, right?
Marcus Johnson: Mm.
Tiffani Montez: And it is a significant portion of the funds remain uncovered.
There are financial consequences as well as costs to reputation and trust that Binance is gonna actually have to deal with.
Marcus Johnson: Mm-hmm. Will there be, if any, uh, regulatory, regulatory... Ugh, I've been in America too long. One of the ways, uh, changes that come from this incident?
Grace Broadbent: I mean, I think one thing, as Tiffany just mentioned, is trust.
Like, yes, the market didn't [00:14:00] move too much in reaction, but it is adding to the larger trust problem that still surrounds the crypto industry. I write a lot about crypto payments and stable coins, and all these stable coin issuers are pushing stable coin payments, but how do you get consumers to trust these payment methods- Mm
and show the clear benefits that they have? And it, almost every survey we do, it's consumers don't trust them. And if they're just keep reading in headlines, $6.30 billion hack, that's not really helping the problem at all. Um, so I think it's a continued, even if it's on inherently, as we were just discussing, more of an deeper AI security problem than a crypto problem, it's still really not helping win over customers that may be skeptical of cryptocurrency or stable coins or these companies.
Marcus Johnson: Mm-hmm.
Tiffani Montez: I think regulation could follow- Mm ... if these companies don't do [00:15:00] the right thing for their, for their customers. So I think that's typically when regulation follows, right? Is when something, someone is wronged somewhere else. So depending on how well they actually really recover in this long term, and how much money they actually get back, and whether or not they make customers that were impacted whole, I think is gonna send a big signal to regulators about whether or not they should actually step in.
Marcus Johnson: Yeah. Yeah, that's a good point. When it comes to regulatory changes, uh, Jeff Koh, chief analyst at ViaBTC, um, said the greater near-term impact on cr- on crypto markets is likely to have come from US midterm elections, since a change in party control- Mm-hmm ... of Congress could have meaning- meaningful implications for how crypto market structure, uh, legislation moves forward.
Let's end with this. How, uh, Grace, I'll go to you first. How will this hack change the cryptocurrency universe, if at all? What will be the fallout from this?
Grace Broadbent: I think the biggest [00:16:00] implication, as Tiffany was mentioning, is just gonna be, you know, what regulations come out of this. Already we've been Seeing somewhat successfully, somewhat unsuccessfully Congress and Senate trying to pass more crypto regulations.
Um, there is the hope that the CLARITY Act would pass this last session. Um, it did not, and so that's kinda on the back burner right now. But will something that made s- big headlines like this and customers losing money, even if they're gonna get recovery from it, will this kinda push regulators over the edge to actually make a change and start dealing with these crypto companies more so like other banks?
Marcus Johnson: The CLARITY Act in a sentence w- for listeners.
Grace Broadbent: The CLARITY Act is really just a bill that's designed to establish, um, a regulatory structure for both crypto and stable coins- Mm-hmm ... and which federal agency, [00:17:00] um, has control over each.
Marcus Johnson: Okay. Uh, Tiffany, how about for you? What, what would this hack, uh, change about the cryptocurrency universe?
Tiffani Montez: I think it's gonna raise the bar for companies and the infrastructure supporting crypto. And the exchanges and other platforms will face more pressure, um, to strengthen security and to protect customers' assets.
Marcus Johnson: Mm-hmm. Lastly, do we... I'm just surprised that investors are happy to charge ahead with this technology, 'cause there was a New York Times piece that pointed out crypto has struggled with major theft since the tech's inception in 2008.
Um, this kinda circles back to the top, Tiffany, the first thing k- you said. Industry pioneers, it says, view digital coins as a renegade alternative to banks, a type of money outside of the supervision of governments or big businesses. These losses are one thing, the money lost in this hack, but the crypto world must reckon with an era of fast evolving hacking techniques and growing risks.
Even as President Trump has endorsed the industry and sought to bring it into the mainstream, some crypto firms still struggle with the [00:18:00] basic work of any financial company, keeping customer money safe. Even though this wasn't it, um, uh, a structural issue, the ramifications of this were still pretty significant and they were still able to do this.
Are you sur- both surprised at all that, um, this hasn't slowed down the cryptocurrency markets?
Tiffani Montez: I am surprised on one hand, but on the, the other hand, if I just think about crypto in general, I mean, if you're investing in crypto, your risk tolerance has to be pretty high. Mm-hmm. Just given the volatility
Marcus Johnson: Yeah.
Tiffani Montez: Of, of the currency. Yeah. So, like, your risk tolerance is already up here. So, like, what is your risk tolerance? Um, and do you maybe care as much as a normal consumer that has $10,000 in their savings account? I think risk tolerance- Mm-hmm ... is probably a little bit different from that perspective.
Marcus Johnson: Yeah. A- and things have changed, I guess.
Um, people's view on crypto ha- has [00:19:00] changed, uh, in the last, what, 10 years or so. And Anchorage Digital Head of Research David, uh, Lawant was saying Bitcoin and crypto are not these hot topic assets like tech stocks that investors are fleeing in and out of. Uh, the current holder base is pretty strong. Uh, and they're able to look at things with a slightly longer term view, um, that's playing a big role in how Bitcoin is behaving, um, well in this negative market environment.
Um, so maybe the perception on crypto's just shifted.
Grace Broadbent: EMARKETER, we have a forecast that 43.6 million people in the US own crypto. That's roughly 16% of the US population. Okay. Wow. Um, and that is 12% year-over-year growth between 2025 to 2026. So y- it is steadily growing. There's a good- Wow ... chunk of Americans that have this risk tolerance- Yeah.
One in seven ... and are willing to take the long-term bet. So it's, I think it's surprising to people that, you know, aren't in this world [00:20:00] as like some of us, us maybe, and how I am like reading every crypto headline. But it really is, you know, a, a big portion of people are willing to take this risk and kind of see the long-term future in it.
Marcus Johnson: Yeah. I wouldn't have guessed the share was that high. One in seven folks is, is really starting to get up there. All right. Uh, time for a couple of takeaways. I think two here. Cybersecurity is more than just systems. To what you were saying, Tiffany, it's the people around the money. You have to make sure you have policies and procedures in place to make sure people aren't creating too much exposure.
And then, uh, Grace, one from you. Crypto continuing to have a trust problem with consumers as banks and payment providers enter, uh, and make it mainstream. There are still a lot of hurdles to overcome in getting people comfortable using these products. Uh, that's all we've got time for for today's episode.
Thank you so much to my guests. Thank you to Tiffany.
Grace Broadbent: Thank you for inviting me.
Marcus Johnson: And to Grace.
Grace Broadbent: Yeah. Thanks for having me.
Marcus Johnson: Thanks to the production crew, Lance and Luigi. Thanks to everyone for listening to the Mind The Machine Market Podcast, made possible by [00:21:00] AI Digital. Subscribe and follow to hear about new episodes, which we will have on Monday.
But until then, happiest of
weekends.