[00:00:00] Marcus Johnson: Behind every bid is a supply decision most buyers never see. That's why they turn to Smart Supply, AI Digital Supply Intelligence solution, scoring and gating every path before the DSP bids, so inventory arrives optimized for your KPI. Learn more at aidigital.com.
[00:00:21] Marcus Johnson: Hey gang, it's Monday, November 16th. Woo, good save. Marissa, Rachel, and listeners welcome to Behind the Numbers, the marketer podcast made possible by AI Digital. Still working, trying to work out if that's the right month. It is. I'm Marcus, and joining me for today's conversation we have the, uh, the ... What's her name?
[00:00:40] Rachel Wolff: The
[00:00:40] Marcus Johnson: only . The only analyst. The o- the one, the only- ... marketing and advertising briefing analyst, maybe, living in Boston, Marissa Jones.
[00:00:48] Marisa Jones: Hi Marcus. I'm excited to be here.
[00:00:50] Marcus Johnson: Hello there. And we also have the retail and e-commerce briefing analyst, there might be others, living in New York, Rachel Wolf.
[00:00:57] Rachel Wolff: Hello everyone.
[00:00:58] Rachel Wolff: Excited to be here.
[00:00:59] Marcus Johnson: [00:01:00] Hello. That introduction was unhinged- ... as Victoria, who used to edit this show, would say. Today's fact.
[00:01:10] Marcus Johnson: All right, where did the term jack-o'-lantern come from? So jack-o'-lantern, for people wondering, uh, is a carved pumpkin, turnip, or any root vegetable lit from the inside by a candle or a light, used primarily as a Halloween decoration. This is not a thing that we do in England. It's super dangerous. And so messy.
[00:01:31] Marcus Johnson: So I just carved my first one down in Virginia a few weeks ago. Shout out to my friends down there who set it up for me, and then we watched The Nightmare Before Christmas, which is my favorite movie of all time. They're very sweet. Uh, wonderful evening. Uh, but I didn't know what I was in for. I didn't realize you have to, like, really hollow it out with your hands.
[00:01:47] Marcus Johnson: It's, uh ... It was a hideous experience. But a lot of fun. I wanted to do Jack Skellington from the movie, from The Nightmare Before Christmas, and he had a surprisingly complicated smile. So I was there for [00:02:00] hours. Anyway, you guys have done this before, I imagine? American tradition. Yes. Yes. Okay.
[00:02:03] Rachel Wolff: As a kid, yeah.
[00:02:04] Rachel Wolff: Okay. But I was always terrible at it.
[00:02:06] Marcus Johnson: Rachel's like, "As a grownup, that's a no." Yeah,
[00:02:07] Marisa Jones: I th- I've never been very good at it. Okay. I think it's much harder than it seems.
[00:02:11] Rachel Wolff: Yeah. It- And I'm curious about the turnip bit of it. Like, you- how do you make a jack-o'-lantern out of a turnip?
[00:02:17] Marcus Johnson: It's difficult as hell. Uh, so I'll explain.
[00:02:20] Marcus Johnson: So where jack-o'-lantern came from, it explains the turnip bit a little bit as well. So the name Jack was a common seventh, uh, 17th century British slang term for a generic man or boy. So folks who saw a local night watchman patrolling a dark street with a light would, um, refer to him as Jack of the lantern.
[00:02:38] Marcus Johnson: And by the 1700s, the name was given to a flickering swamp gas, or swamp gasses, that looked like a person carrying a light. Um, superstitious locals called them jack-o'-lanterns, believing they were trickster spirits. Irish folklore blame these lights on Stingy Jack, a deceitful man banned from both heaven and hell.
[00:02:59] Marcus Johnson: Uh, [00:03:00] doomed to wander the dark forever, he carried a glowing ember inside a hollowed out turnip. Uh, I think this was given to him, the ember was given to him by the devil. Uh, and so when Irish immigrants moved to North America in the 19th century, they brought the custom of carving turnips to ward off Jack's wandering spirit.
[00:03:19] Marcus Johnson: They quickly switched to Native American pumpkins, 'cause to what Rachel was just saying, um, turnips are difficult. And, uh, pumpkins are larger, hollow, and a lot easier to carve than a hard root vegetable.
[00:03:32] Rachel Wolff: All right, the more you know.
[00:03:35] Marcus Johnson: I know. I'll be trying a turnip
[00:03:37] Marisa Jones: next year. A
[00:03:37] Marcus Johnson: useless fact. Yeah, right. Some 11.
[00:03:40] Marcus Johnson: Uh, pumpkin was hard enough. But I had a lot of fun, so thank you guys. Anyway, today's real topic: the big three questions surrounding Amazon.
[00:03:53] Marcus Johnson: All right, we have some takeaways for you guys at the end of the episode. We added those recently, so make sure you stay tuned for those for a quick wrap-up of what we talked about. [00:04:00] But, um, we'll set the table. Amazon, Q3, how did they do? So just over $200, uh, billion again, 202 in Q3. That's up 12%, uh, a little bit down from last Q3.
[00:04:13] Marcus Johnson: Uh, most of their money, uh, about 34% of it, is coming from online store net sales. Uh, that was 68 and a half billion. Uh, but very slow growth, just 2%. Uh, that's down from 10% the last Q3. Uh, some other interesting line items, AWS just rocket ship, 46 billion, accounting for 22% of all their money now. Uh, that was growth of 40%, nearly double what it did a year ago in Q3.
[00:04:43] Marcus Johnson: And then advertising, uh, grew 11%. That's down about half. Grew about 24%, uh, last Q3. That's making about close to $20 billion. Um, so that's how Amazon did in Q3, and some other numbers as well. But, um, we're here to talk about the big three [00:05:00] questions for Amazon. So earnings aside, maybe earnings included, uh, what is on, uh, Amazon's minds, investors' minds, analysts' minds?
[00:05:08] Marcus Johnson: When you zoom out, what is Amazon thinking about? What are people thinking about for Amazon? Rachel, I'll start with you. What's top of your list?
[00:05:16] Rachel Wolff: So my first question is, you know, do Amazon's Q3 earnings really matter? And I don't mean that in an existential sense, but more like, do they offer any useful insight into how the company is performing, how the US consumer is feeling or spending?
[00:05:33] Rachel Wolff: And I think it's a little bit mixed, and really that's because- Mm ... Amazon moved Prime Day, and I think I'm just gonna blame it all on that. But essentially, you know, the data is pretty muddy. They themselves said that the move negatively impacted year over year growth by about 400 basis points.
[00:05:50] Marcus Johnson: So just for folks, they moved it from when to when?
[00:05:53] Rachel Wolff: So they moved it from Q3 to Q2 to- Right ... avoid, uh, conflicting with, you know, World Cup [00:06:00] advertising- Yes ... enthusiasm and all of that. Yeah. Um, and so that has really kind of made it hard to figure out how well Amazon is doing h- if people are spending more, um, implications for its ad business as well Um, and I was honestly most taken by the fact that even with the shift, that sales still grew year over year, which to me is a sign of a healthy consumer, right?
[00:06:23] Rachel Wolff: I mean, even without Prime Day, Amazon is still managing to get people to spend more.
[00:06:28] Marcus Johnson: Yeah. How much do we wanna attribute to this shift in, in Prime Day? Is it, is it most of it? Is it some of it, and there's other stories going on? What would you, what would you say?
[00:06:37] Rachel Wolff: I think there's a lot of it, and the other thing to keep in mind is that last year, I believe, was the first time that Prime Day was four days.
[00:06:43] Rachel Wolff: So again, you know, like it has- Yeah ... an outsize impact on Amazon's performance the year, uh, this year, this partic- this quarter.
[00:06:51] Marcus Johnson: Mm-hmm.
[00:06:51] Rachel Wolff: Um, so I think it's just a little bit difficult to tell, and I think, you know, there's been a lot of headlines about, oh, uh, stores only grew [00:07:00] 2% and advertising growth is way down.
[00:07:01] Rachel Wolff: But I think you have to take into account that mitigating factor.
[00:07:06] Marcus Johnson: Yeah.
[00:07:06] Marisa Jones: Mm-hmm. I think the, um, figures on advertising growth are especially surprising that it kind of spooked people that much or seemed like that big. Obviously at first it does seem like quite a big decline.
[00:07:19] Marcus Johnson: Mm.
[00:07:20] Marisa Jones: But they have cited like several factors.
[00:07:22] Marisa Jones: They were a bit vague in their initial earnings release. They just said Prime Day, changing timing, and then other timing factors. In their earnings call they did clarify that was, um, due to the timing of when NBA On Prime aired and then changes they made last year to their search engine, uh, marketing programs as two other key drivers of, of ad, ads decreasing so much.
[00:07:47] Marisa Jones: Mm-hmm. Um, so it really is, to me, not necessarily this deceleration, a sign that their business is actually like fundamentally weakening in any way. Uh- Mm ... but it is kind of, at [00:08:00] first, a shocking figure to see just 'cause it is such a stark difference to previous quarters.
[00:08:04] Marcus Johnson: It does seem like it's getting harder and harder to figure out- What are the right indicators to look at in terms- Mm-hmm
[00:08:12] Marcus Johnson: of trying to determine whether people are gonna spend or not? We're gonna be doing some episodes in the future, um, with our, uh, around consumer insights because we're, we're working on that part, um, of our research. And, um, I think it's fascinating to look at what are the metrics that tell the story anymore, because it used to be GDP growth, it used to be inflation, it used to be unemployment, um, things like that.
[00:08:33] Marcus Johnson: Uh, even the retail, uh, numbers from, from the earnings, and now they can tell one story, uh, even consumer confidence. Uh, like how much of that is a, is an important indicator in the, uh, the, you know, the stew that creates, um, how consumers are feeling. What are the right ingredients, uh, today versus what they used to be.
[00:08:54] Marcus Johnson: Comps getting harder and harder, whether that's, uh, sales longer than they were before, sales at different [00:09:00] times than they were before, new sales maybe being introduced. So, uh, it does feel like it's an, uh, even more of a moving target than it ever has been.
[00:09:09] Rachel Wolff: Yeah, and the sheer sprawl of Amazon's business also makes it very difficult.
[00:09:14] Marcus Johnson: Yes. Yeah, 2% growth in online store net sales around the pandemic would've been a problem because it accounted for half of their business. Um, 2% growth in online store net sales today, it's about a third of their business. It's still a lot, it's still the majority, but as I mentioned before, AWS growing 40% helps significantly, um, to cushion that blow.
[00:09:37] Marcus Johnson: Um- Marissa, what's one of your top questions for the company?
[00:09:41] Marisa Jones: So one of my top questions is will AI shopping assistants become Amazon's next major advertising opportunity? I think the answer is really kind of possibly. They are already really laying the groundwork for this. Um, they already include sponsored and AI-powered conversational ads in their [00:10:00] Alexa for Shopping agentic assistant, but they really highlighted in Q3, they said that Alexa for Shopping reaches over 400 million customers within the last 12 months, and customer interactions increased 570% year over year.
[00:10:14] Marisa Jones: Uh, they simultaneously introduced over 100 capabilities throughout the quarter for Alexa for Shopping, including things like creating gift lists and completing shopping-related tasks through conversations with this agentic tool, which does suggest to me that conversational shopping is becoming a more meaningful part of Amazon's business and the Amazon experience, which obviously could translate to, and is already translating to, new opportunities for brands to reach customers while they are actively making decisions but in a new kind of unfamiliar way.
[00:10:47] Marcus Johnson: Mm-hmm. Yeah, Rachel, you wr- wrote about this recently, and that's what, uh, sparked one of my questions, which is how much can, uh, Alexa move the holiday shopping needle this year- Right ... uh, to what Marissa was just [00:11:00] saying, um, new capabilities, creating holiday gift lists, wedding registries, resolving billing issues, you write, maximizing Prime, other subscription benefits, updating- Mm-hmm
[00:11:09] Marcus Johnson: delivery instructions, things like that. Uh, what do you make of, uh, the AI, uh, shopping efforts?
[00:11:15] Rachel Wolff: I mean, I think that Amazon definitely has an opportunity with AI shopping, right? Just the sheer number of people who are on Amazon who are engaging with Alexa for shopping, whether intentionally or unintentionally.
[00:11:26] Rachel Wolff: I, you know, have to wonder how many of those, was it 400 million plus people are actively searching out Alexa for shopping or just kind of stumbling across it as they go through- Mm ... the Amazon experience. Yeah. But I think, you know, one notable stat that Amazon highlighted was that US customers who use Alexa for shopping spend 50% more per order than those who don't, right?
[00:11:46] Rachel Wolff: So this is obviously a very- Wow ... engaged shopper base. Um, but it is also kind of a risk when you start introducing ads into these types of experiences because you don't know exactly how that might undermine the [00:12:00] trust that consumers have in the results that Alexa for shopping is pulling for you, right?
[00:12:04] Marisa Jones: Mm-hmm.
[00:12:05] Rachel Wolff: Um, I was just, we have a handy chart, um, which is that over half of US adults trust AI information less when they c- think that answers are influenced by advertisers. So, you know, even if Amazon is upfront about saying that these are separate things, there could still be the sort of knock-on effect of, you know, having ads close enough that people think that there's some sort of, you know, pay for play situation happening.
[00:12:31] Marisa Jones: Mm-hmm.
[00:12:31] Rachel Wolff: So I think it's a delicate balance. And then the other thing is that, you know, the more money that gets funneled into, um, these ads, the, you know, not exactly threaten, but it does threaten the core of Amazon's ad business, which is search advertising, right? And so if you're Amazon, you have to figure out how do you balance this opportunity with the need to protect one of your core cash cows.
[00:12:52] Marcus Johnson: It's interesting 'cause it, it seems like, I wanted to talk, one of my questions was what we should we make of Amazon blocking Meta's Muse? Yeah. Uh, [00:13:00] and, um, they blocked Meta's AI shopping agent, Muse, from operating on its platform. They cited privacy, safety, terms of use violations, things like that. But our senior analyst, Gadjo Sevilla, was citing, uh, Dima Okunev, I think how you pronounce the name, of paid social marketing firm, iCanvas.
[00:13:17] Marcus Johnson: Um, basically saying Amazon isn't afraid of losing a toaster sale, it's afraid of losing the minutes before someone buys the toaster. That's where sponsored listings do their work. An agent could send the shopper straight to one product and the sale would survive while the ad exposure opportunity evaporates.
[00:13:34] Marcus Johnson: So, uh, yeah, it's interesting thinking about why they might wanna control that experience. Time on platform obviously leads to, um, ad sales, which is a big part of their business, not just, not just selling, selling bits and pieces. Um- I do...
[00:13:48] Marisa Jones: Sorry ...
[00:13:48] Marcus Johnson: please. No, no, no- Yeah ... never sorry
[00:13:49] Marisa Jones: Um, I do think it's very interesting.
[00:13:52] Marisa Jones: I don't really have an answer to it, but the point you bring up, Rachel, about what does this mean for their kind of core search business, is [00:14:00] it... To me, the question is kind of is it a fundamental transformation of their search business? Is this the experience now, or is it kind of just a way to create incremental advertising opportunities?
[00:14:12] Marisa Jones: Um, also to your point about how many people are actually intentionally using this, um, this doesn't necessarily change the data, but for me, I've many times accidentally stumbled on Alexa for shopping, uh, without intending to. Um, so it is almost kind of those questions do come into consideration on how legitimate, or at least how, how much intent there really is to interact with Alexa for shopping.
[00:14:37] Marcus Johnson: Mm-hmm. Yeah, intent the key word there.
[00:14:41] Marisa Jones: Mm-hmm.
[00:14:41] Marcus Johnson: Um, Rachel, back to you. Yes. What else do you have on your list?
[00:14:45] Rachel Wolff: So another one of my questions is, what levers can Amazon pull to accelerate e-commerce growth? You know, again, they only grew 2% this quarter, so what do they have at their disposal? One is, we talk about this quarter after quarter, but [00:15:00] faster delivery speeds, right?
[00:15:01] Rachel Wolff: I mean, they talk about it quarter after quarter, just getting items to d- people's doors faster, especially groceries. That's really becoming, um, a key part of their push. Everyday essentials, fresh groceries, growing about three times faster than the rest of Amazon's store business, and representing about half of all units sold in Q3, which to me is, again, like a huge leap forward for Amazon's- Mm-hmm
[00:15:24] Rachel Wolff: grocery business. It helps drive increased order frequency. It means that people are doing more of their shopping on Amazon, which again, is great for user retention and lifetime value. But I think the other key is Amazon Prime, and the question has always been, what new benefits can Amazon offer to Prime members to make the service stickier, to get people to sign up?
[00:15:48] Rachel Wolff: Um, and the most recent benefit, which they just launched, is a partnership with Uber Eats to, um, basically give Prime members access to restaurant delivery through Amazon, and this would replace the existing- Mm ... [00:16:00] Grubhub partnership that they've had for the past, I believe, two years.
[00:16:03] Marisa Jones: Hmm.
[00:16:03] Rachel Wolff: Um, and so, you know, Prime members now, they have access to the country's largest restaurant delivery network.
[00:16:09] Rachel Wolff: They don't need an Uber account to access it. Um- Oh, wow ... and it gives Amazon also an entry into the restaurant delivery market, which, you know, could provide new advertising opportunities and expand its marketplace even further.
[00:16:23] Marisa Jones: Yeah.
[00:16:24] Marcus Johnson: Mm-hmm. Yeah, one of the questions I had was can Amazon, based on the article you wrote about this, can Amazon turn fast, reliable delivery of fresh groceries into a real habit?
[00:16:32] Marcus Johnson: Uh, the number you, uh, the line you cited, the number of active customers who buy perishables monthly is up more than 50% since the beginning of 2020. Six groceries, fresh groceries accounting for six of the top 20 bestsellers, you say, on Amazon's site. Yeah, this is a good one. This is a good one. Um, and yeah, the question as well, which you had in there about what perks, uh, can they add, uh, to really add new Prime members or keep [00:17:00] existing, um- I think it's a really good one, especially as Walmart tries to strengthen Walmart+ as best as it can.
[00:17:07] Marcus Johnson: I have one more to throw out there. Uh, our principal retail analyst, Zak Stambor, um, inspired this one. He was writing about the catalog. He was saying Amazon is sending millions of copies of its 2026 holiday kids gift book to consumers' homes. The ninth year, I couldn't believe they've been doing this for nine years, uh, that Amazon has shipped a holiday toy catalog.
[00:17:30] Marcus Johnson: So my question was, can the catalog make a real comeback? Um, I had a few numbers from a previous episode which was speaking to this drive towards analog coming back, analog hobbies. Uh, people buying records was one number. US vinyl sales crossing the $1 billion mark in 2025 dollars for the first time since 1987, now accounting for 9% of music sales.
[00:17:53] Marcus Johnson: That's double pre-pandemic 2019. And then also second point, independent booksellers making a comeback. The number of [00:18:00] independent booksellers in the US skyrocketing nearly 70% in the last five years according to, uh, American booksellers. And so I was looking at this chart we can throw up on the screen from Tinuiti.
[00:18:12] Marcus Johnson: Nearly one in five consumers expect catalogs will lead to gift discovery. Folks can see on the chart in-store displays or signage in terms of how do you discover holiday gifts, in-store displays and signage is, is out in front with 45%, search engines 37, social media 36, et cetera, et cetera. But catalogs is neck and neck with streaming video services.
[00:18:33] Marcus Johnson: And so I wonder how much of a comeback can catalogs actually make?
[00:18:38] Rachel Wolff: Yeah, I think there's almost, it's kind of quaint to say, but there's almost a novelty to them now- Mm-hmm ... because people don't really get so many catalogs these days. And so when you do receive one, it is a sense of excitement. I will say, I did get Amazon's, uh, toy catalog, and it was kind of disappointing in the fact that it's really small.
[00:18:57] Rachel Wolff: And- Oh ... I feel like for these types of [00:19:00] initiatives to work, they have to have some production value, right? Like, you kind of have to make it, like, I don't know, the Vogue September issue where you have these glossy pages and, like, you know, full-on photo shoots and that sort of thing. Um, but I do think, I ac- really like the idea of having a holiday catalog or just catalogs in general, and I really wish more brands would do that.
[00:19:22] Marcus Johnson: Yeah. He said, uh, Zach was saying this year's... Uh, I agree with you in terms of the size of it and the production qu- quality of it because, um, as a kid, I remember it being, I mean, just endless amounts of toys. Uh, and the thing was huge, basically like a phone book. But he says this year's edition features, um, more than 600 toys and gifts, an original illustrated story, and family-friendly activities.
[00:19:42] Marcus Johnson: I don't know if that, that, those things have been in previous, uh, editions, but, uh, yeah, can they do more to it to make it really quite invaluable? Um, and I'm sure parents would probably rather enjoy the idea of their kids maybe flicking through, uh, a book, uh, as opposed to, uh, giving them access to the Amazon account and [00:20:00] saying "Go,
[00:20:00] Marisa Jones: go search."
[00:20:01] Rachel Wolff: Ask Alexa. "Alexa, buy me these toys."
[00:20:04] Marcus Johnson: Exactly. Um, all right. There, there are top questions. Let's put together a consensus, uh, top three big questions surrounding Amazon. Uh, Marissa, I'll let you go first. What, what, what do you have?
[00:20:15] Marisa Jones: Um, I'm gonna say Rachel's first question on do their Q3 results really matter that much.
[00:20:20] Marcus Johnson: Yeah. Great one. Uh, Rachel, what about you?
[00:20:23] Rachel Wolff: I'm gonna go for Marissa's first question, uh, about can Amazon- Oh, yeah. That's fine ... I know, sorry.
[00:20:28] Marcus Johnson: It's fine. Marissa did good.
[00:20:29] Rachel Wolff: Can Amazon turn, um, Alexa for Shopping into a larger advertising opportunity?
[00:20:35] Marcus Johnson: Uh, very nice. Uh, and just so I have a, ba, ba, ba, bla- Are you gonna
[00:20:42] Rachel Wolff: vote for yourself, Marcus?
[00:20:44] Marcus Johnson: Maybe. You should. I should. Uh, no, it's related to your one about, um, uh, uh, e-commerce growth. Uh, so I think, uh, basically what else can Amazon do? I think the delivery of fresh, uh, groceries, uh, and [00:21:00] turning that into a real habit I think is, is really interesting, 'cause that seems to be g- quite a good growth driver for them at the moment.
[00:21:05] Marcus Johnson: Um, all right, that's all we've got time for, for, for this episode. Thank you so much to my guests, uh, for today. Thank you so much to, uh, Marissa.
[00:21:12] Marisa Jones: Thank you for having me, Marcus.
[00:21:14] Marcus Johnson: And to Rachel.
[00:21:16] Rachel Wolff: Thank you. Sorry, I think the Wi-Fi just cut out, so we might have to do that again.
[00:21:19] Marcus Johnson: Okay. That's your excuse?
[00:21:21] Rachel Wolff: For cutting you off.
[00:21:23] Marcus Johnson: I thought you'd left. I looked up and I was like, "Oh, no, she's still there. She's just ignoring me. I'll just get on with it." No. Uh, thank you to the production crew. Uh, thanks to, uh, who's on the production crew? L- Luigi and Lance helping us out with this one. Thanks to everyone for listening to Behind the Numbers e-market Podcast, made possible by AI Digital.
[00:21:39] Marcus Johnson: Wednesday, Suzy will be speaking with Nestle Purina on the Reimagining Retail show. On Thursday, we have the, uh, podcast In the Game, where we'll be talking about the rise of the athlete as a brand. And of course, tune in Friday for more Behind the
[00:22:00] Numbers.