AI agents could upend top-of-wallet status for card issuers and BNPL providers

The news: As agentic commerce gains traction, it could have profound consequences for what payment providers used to think of as “top of wallet” status—eroding consumer loyalty and making agentic tie-ins an important part of providers’ online checkout strategy. 

Affirm is trying to get out ahead of those changes. It published a white paper with Consumer Reports developing a framework for how agents should surface and recommend different payment options. 

The protocol weights repayment costs and risks and offers a ranked list of which payment methods it recommends.

Why this matters: AI is slowly disrupting how US consumers shop. AI-driven retail ecommerce sales will account for 3.2% of US retail ecommerce sales this year, surpassing 15% by 2030, per our forecast. While little of this volume is currently agentic, consumers are shifting their discovery phases to AI—which could lead to greater willingness to let agents transact on their behalf.

Implication for payment providers: Agents start checking out for consumers, they might not make the same payment method choices depending on what they’re expected to prioritize—and how complete a picture of a consumer’s finances they have. 

For example, a bot ordered to maximize rewards might recommend opening new store cards at every merchant they fill an order at—or activate card offers on their least-used card that consumers weren’t even aware of. 

However, this kind of decision-making is still more of a pipe dream—giving agents a clear view of a consumer’s finances, real-time debt obligations, and available payment methods would involve enormous access to consumers’ various accounts and financial information.

It’s one thing to connect a wallet to see which cards you already have on file. It’s another to see credit limits, current statements, APRs, and how many different BNPL loans a consumer has across different providers.

While others work on how to get agents to recommend new payment methods, Visa, Mastercard, and American Express’ backing of ChatGPT’s new digital wallet suggest where the industry may be headed: The providers who design and build the infrastructure for agentic payments will ensure their rails get priority placement. 

This content is part of EMARKETER’s subscription Briefings, where we pair daily updates with data and analysis from forecasts and research reports. Our Briefings prepare you to start your day informed, to provide critical insights in an important meeting, and to understand the context of what’s happening in your industry. Non-clients can click here to get a demo of our full platform and coverage.

You've read 0 of 2 free articles this month.

Get more articles - create your free account today!